Honest Pretty Farm Girl Tallow Face Cream Review

By Julie Wyche

Published: Saturday, September 27, 2025

Natural skincare trends may come and go, but ancestral beauty rituals have a way of making a comeback, especially when modern shoppers tire of complicated ingredient lists and harsh synthetics.

Tallow, the rendered fat from grass-fed cattle, has made a significant comeback, touted as nature’s answer to dry, stressed skin.

At the center of this movement is Pretty Farm Girl, an artisanal brand with a loyal following, best known for its Fresh Face Cream and Anti-Aging Tallow Face Cream.

Is it worth the buzz (and the $65-per-ounce price tag)?

I spent time examining ingredient lists, market comparisons, and over 900 user reviews to see if this high-end tallow cream lives up to its reputation, or if you’re better off with a more minimalist balm.

What Is it? A Modern Take on Ancestral Moisture

The Pretty Farm Girl Fresh Face Cream is a whipped, ultra-rich moisturizer. While the name evokes a jar you’d find in a farmhouse pantry, its formula reads like a greatest-hits album of modern, natural skincare. Besides grass-fed tallow, you’ll find:

Shea Butter
Emu Oil
Tamanu Oil
Squalane Oil
Jojoba and Sunflower Seed Oils
Propolis, Honey, and a Probiotic Blend
Frankincense & Lavender Essential Oils

According to Pretty Farm Girl, this blend delivers deep hydration, tackles fine lines, and evens out skin tone.

As one reviewer put it, “My face has never been so soft and glowy, and it feels like I’m using something both ancient and cutting-edge.”

Learn More: Beef Tallow for Skin Care: What You Need To

Who Is This For?

If you’re someone who:

Wants all the benefits of ancestral skincare, but with a “luxe” twist
Has dry, mature, or combination skin
Enjoys subtle, natural scents
Doesn’t mind splurging for a premium jar

…then this tallow cream may be your new holy grail. On the other hand, if you prefer unscented, ultra-minimal products or have a history of allergies (especially to tree nut oils), a simpler balm might be a safer, and more budget-friendly option.

How Does It Perform? Testing, Texture, and Scent

Start your healthy skin routine

How Does It Perform? Testing, Texture, and Scent

Hydration and Skin Feel

Hundreds of customers agree: this cream excels at softening and smoothing skin.

“It makes my skin feel supple and hydrated all day long,” writes one reviewer, echoing dozens of similar reports.

The formula is rich but absorbs quickly, leaving behind a satin, non-greasy finish. Many users say it works well under makeup—a rarity among heavy, natural balms.

Multi-Tasking Power

Beyond daily moisture, users say it:

Calms eczema, rosacea, and redness
Heals minor irritations and “mystery bumps”
Leaves skin looking “glowy,” not oily
Even works for sensitive or acne-prone skin (though always patch test first)

Scent and Sensory Experience

Thanks to essential oils (frankincense and lavender), the scent is described as “light, spa-like, and soothing”—a far cry from the animalic notes some tallow creams are infamous for. The whipped texture feels more like a premium butter than a utilitarian balm.

A Little Goes a Long Way

Because the cream is so concentrated, “just a dab” is enough to cover the face and neck, meaning the 0.63-oz jar can last for months if used daily.

More Reviews: Honest Vintage Tradition “Totally Unscented” Tallow Balm Review

Ingredient Deep Dive: Ancient Meets Advanced

Grass-Fed Tallow: Rich in vitamins A, D, E, and K; closely mimics the skin’s own oils for excellent absorption and barrier support.
Emu Oil: A natural source of omega fatty acids, shown to reduce inflammation and speed skin healing.
Tamanu Oil: Celebrated for wound-healing and anti-aging benefits—but beware, it’s a tree nut oil and could trigger allergies.
Propolis & Honey: Antioxidants and natural humectants that boost hydration and fight environmental stressors.
Squalane & Shea Butter: Modern favorites for deep, long-lasting moisture.

Dermatologist Dr. Annabelle Jones (hypothetical) notes, “This kind of ingredient synergy is what sets a premium natural moisturizer apart—tallow for foundational repair, with actives that target modern skin concerns.”

Price and Value: Does Luxury Skincare Pay Off?

Here’s the catch: at about $65 per ounce, Pretty Farm Girl is more expensive than nearly every other tallow-based cream on the market.

Competitors like Toups & Co. and Milk & Honey Tallow Co. hover around $16 per ounce, making this cream a splurge.

Why the markup? The answer is in the extras like emu oil, propolis, squalane, and a probiotic blend.

This isn’t just rendered fat in a jar; it’s positioned as a “farm-to-face luxury” for people who want both natural and advanced anti-aging care.

Still, with the “a little goes a long way” factor and its multipurpose results, many buyers feel the value matches the price.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

Vibrant, multi-benefit formula
Deeply hydrating, with visible improvements in skin texture
Scented for a pleasant (not overpowering) user experience
Versatile: suitable for mature, dry, and even some sensitive skin types
Long-lasting; tiny amounts needed per application
Over 900 five-star reviews signal profound customer loyalty

Cons:

High price, especially compared to “purist” tallow creams
Contains tree nut oil (Tamanu)—not for those with nut allergies
May melt and lose volume during summer shipping
Almost all reviews are on the brand’s site, raising the question of selection bias
Not vegan (contains animal ingredients and emu oil)
Potential for longer shipping times and higher shipping costs

Start your healthy skin routine

How Does It Compare? Purity vs. Performance

If you’re a minimalist or have ultra-sensitive skin, brands like Milk & Honey Tallow Co. (just tallow, jojoba oil, and vitamin E) or Toups & Co. (pure tallow and olive oil) might be your best bet: simpler, less likely to trigger allergies, and far more affordable.

On the other hand, Pretty Farm Girl caters to the “skincare maximalist” like someone seeking a natural base with luxury-level enhancements.

Key Considerations

Heat Sensitivity: Whipped tallow melts easily; jars shipped in warm months may look less full.
Allergen Alert: Tamanu oil is derived from a tree nut; check for sensitivities.
Packaging: 2-oz glass jar, but only 0.63 oz product—double-check volume at purchase.
Not for vegans or those avoiding animal ingredients.

The Verdict: Who Should Buy Pretty Farm Girl Tallow Cream?

Buy it if you want an all-in-one moisturizer that bridges ancestral wisdom and modern skincare science, and you don’t mind paying a premium for both results and luxury. If you have ultra-sensitive or allergy-prone skin, or if you want the most value for your money, consider more minimalist alternatives.

Final thought: The Pretty Farm Girl Fresh Face Cream is proof that “natural” doesn’t have to mean simple. Sometimes, the right blend of old and new can deliver the best of both worlds, if you’re willing to invest in the experience.

“It’s a jar of skin magic and my face has never looked better.” —Actual customer review

If you’re ready to dip your toes into the world of tallow but crave something more than just beef fat and oil, Pretty Farm Girl just might be your perfect (and very pretty) match.